Zimmer NexGen Knee Replacement Claims

Some patients who received a Zimmer NexGen knee replacement implant have experienced complications, including ongoing pain and the need for further surgical intervention. If you have suffered difficulties following knee replacement surgery and believe the implant may have failed, you may be entitled to pursue a claim.

Zimmer NextGen knee replacement

Pursuing Compensation for Patients Affected by Zimmer NexGen Knee Replacements

The Zimmer NexGen knee replacement system has been the subject of concerns regarding premature failure and the need for revision surgery in certain cases. Where a medical device does not perform as intended and causes injury, pain, or additional surgical intervention, affected patients may be entitled to pursue a compensation claim.

Knee replacement surgery is intended to relieve pain and restore mobility. When a device fails, the consequences can be significant, including ongoing discomfort, reduced function, instability, and the need for further complex procedures. Revision surgery can carry additional risks and may involve a prolonged recovery period. If you have experienced complications linked to a Zimmer NexGen knee implant, it is important to seek legal advice on your options.

At McCarthy + Co Solicitors LLP, we advise individuals across Ireland who believe they have suffered harm due to defective medical products. We provide clear, practical guidance to help you understand whether a claim may be available and how the legal process applies to your circumstances.

Patients who have received certain Zimmer NexGen knee implants have reported complications such as the following:

  • Persistent pain following surgery
  • Loosening of the implant
  • Instability or reduced mobility in the joint
  • Early failure requiring revision surgery
  • Inflammation or other adverse reactions

Not all complications will amount to a viable legal claim. However, if a product is determined to be defective or if the associated risks were not properly disclosed, remedies may be pursued under product liability or medical negligence law.

How a claim may arise

Claims involving defective medical devices may be brought under product liability legislation, which can impose strict liability where a product does not provide the level of safety that a person is entitled to expect. In certain circumstances, a claim may also arise where there has been a failure in surgical technique, pre-operative assessment, or post-operative care.

To pursue a claim, it is generally necessary to establish that:

  • The medical device was defective or unsafe.
  • The defect caused injury or loss.
  • You suffered damage as a result, including pain, further surgery, or financial loss.

Our solicitors can review your medical records, obtain independent expert opinions, and advise on whether your circumstances may support a claim.

Why early legal advice is important

Claims involving medical devices can involve complex medical evidence, regulatory considerations, and strict time limits. Acting promptly allows relevant medical documentation to be obtained and assessed by appropriate experts.

If you are concerned about complications following a Zimmer NexGen knee replacement, speaking with one of our experienced solicitors will help you understand your rights and options. Arrange a consultation today by completing our quick and confidential online form.

Call us Freephone to Discuss Your Case:

1800 390 555

Request A Call Back

Get a call back from our legal team at a time that suits you.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Highly rated on TrustPilot

Read the latest reviews written by our happy clients.

Meet John McCarthy

John McCarthy is a partner at McCarthy + Co Solicitors LLP, with more than 20 years of experience in medical negligence and product liability claims. He brought multiple successful claims against DePuy Orthopaedics following the worldwide recall of the ASR hip replacement system, and also leads our work supporting clients fitted with implants that have been the subject of safety notices and recalls, including the Zimmer NexGen knee replacement system.

John holds a diploma in civil litigation from the Law Society of Ireland and is a member of Action Against Medical Accidents (AvMA), the leading patient safety charity. He is also the author of A Patient’s Guide to Bringing a Claim for Medical Negligence. If you have been fitted with a Zimmer NexGen knee replacement and are experiencing problems, you can contact John directly at john@mccarthy.ie.

Frequently Asked Questions

Some of the questions our legal team are often asked in relation to Zimmer NexGen devices.

What is a Zimmer NexGen knee replacement?

Zimmer NexGen is a brand of total knee replacement system made by Zimmer Biomet. A total knee replacement usually involves several components, including parts fixed to the thigh bone and shin bone, and an insert that helps the joint move.

What kinds of problems have been reported with some NexGen components?

Reports and safety notices have described issues that may lead to pain, reduced function, loosening, and, in some cases, the need for revision surgery. Zimmer Biomet has issued recall communications for certain NexGen tibial components, and a report by the BBC investigated the concerning failure rate of a particular component.

Does a recall mean my implant is definitely faulty?

Not necessarily. A recall or safety notice usually means that a manufacturer has identified a potential issue with specific products or product combinations, and it is taking steps to reduce risk. Many people with the same brand of implant may never experience a problem. The key question is how your particular implant has performed, what symptoms you have, and what your treating clinician finds on examination and imaging.

What symptoms should I take seriously after a knee replacement?

You should seek medical advice if you have persistent or worsening pain, swelling, instability, reduced range of motion, difficulty weight bearing, unusual clicking or grinding, signs of infection, or a sudden change in function. These symptoms can have several causes, so it is important to get a clinical assessment.

How do I find out which knee implant I have?

Hospitals usually keep records of the implant used, including stickers with the product name, batch, lot, or serial numbers. You can ask the hospital or your surgeon for your operative notes and implant details. These records can be important if you later need to confirm whether you have a component mentioned in a safety notice.

What does “defective” mean under Irish product liability law?

Under the Liability for Defective Products Act 1991, a product is defective if it fails to provide the safety a person is entitled to expect, taking all the circumstances into account, including the product’s presentation, how it could reasonably be expected to be used, and the time it was put into circulation.

What do I have to prove to bring a product liability claim?

In general, you must be able to show that you suffered damage, that the product was defective, and that the defect caused the damage. Evidence often includes medical records, imaging, expert opinions, and documentation identifying the implant.

How long do I have to make a claim in Ireland?

Time limits are strict, and they depend on the type of claim.

  • For claims under the Liability for Defective Products Act 1991, court proceedings usually must be started within three years. This three-year period generally runs from when the claim arose, or from when you first knew, or should reasonably have known, that you had been injured, that the product may have been defective, and who produced it. There is also a ten-year long stop, which usually runs from when the product was first put into circulation, and it can prevent a claim even if the three-year period has not passed.
  • For many negligence-based injury claims, the limit is two years from the date the cause of action accrued, or the date of knowledge if later.
What should I do now if I am worried about my knee implant?

You should seek medical advice promptly, request your implant details and relevant records, keep a diary of symptoms and appointments, and retain receipts for expenses linked to the problem. You can also report a suspected medical device safety issue to the HPRA.

Which types of scenarios can result in a birth injury claim?

It is possible to bring a compensation claim for a birth injury when your child has suffered an injury during the antenatal care phase, during the intrapartum period or process of delivery, or at any point in the postnatal period – as long as there is evidence of negligence by medical staff.

McCarthy + Co Medical Negligence Team

Our Awards & Accreditations

We are a multi-award winning firm, accredited by the Law Society of Ireland.

Law Firm of the Year - Irish Law Awards
Irish Law Awards 2022 - Winner of Excellence & Innovation in Client Services
Irish Law Awards 2022 - Excellence & Innovation in Client Services
Irish Law Awards 2021 - Litigation Law Firm of the Year (Munster)
Q9000 The Legal Quality Standard of Ireland
Apil Accredited Practice
Law Society of Ireland - Practising Solicitor
Business All-Star Logo
AvMA logo 2026
Irish Law Awards Winner 2014