A recent audit has revealed that out of 561 hip surgeries performed on children aged one to seven since 2021, 79% at Cappagh Hospital and 60% at Temple Street Children’s Hospital were deemed unnecessary. These findings were brought to light in the Dáil by Sinn Féin TD Pearse Doherty, who cited whistleblower allegations suggesting that numerous children underwent unwarranted procedures.
Families affected by these revelations have expressed profound distress. One mother, whose four-year-old daughter had surgery at Cappagh Hospital, reported feeling “sick to her stomach” upon learning that the operation might have been unnecessary. Another family recounted that a consultant recommended bilateral hip surgery for their daughter; however, a second opinion revealed that she did not have the condition requiring such intervention.
In response, Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe emphasised the government’s serious approach to the issue, noting that the audit’s findings are under review. He assured that families will be informed of the outcomes once the report is finalised, acknowledging the significant concern and anxiety among parents regarding the necessity and impact of these surgeries.
Medical negligence in paediatric care
Medical negligence occurs when healthcare professionals fail to meet the accepted standard of care, resulting in harm to the patient. In paediatric cases, this can have long-term consequences for a child’s health and development. Unnecessary surgeries not only expose children to avoidable risks but also represent a serious breach of professional duty and trust.
Steps for parents to protect their legal rights
If you believe your child may have undergone an unnecessary procedure, the following steps can help protect your family’s legal position:
- Seek an Independent Medical Opinion – Consult a qualified, independent medical expert to assess your child’s current health and whether the surgery was appropriate.
- Request Full Medical Records – Obtain all relevant documentation relating to your child’s diagnosis, treatment, and surgical procedures. You are entitled to this information under data protection laws.
- Keep a Detailed Record – Document your child’s post-operative symptoms, any ongoing medical issues, and your communications with hospital staff. This record may be critical if you pursue a legal claim.
- Consult a Solicitor Specialising in Medical Negligence – Engage a solicitor experienced in clinical negligence cases involving children. They can help assess whether you may be entitled to compensation and guide you through the legal process.
Legal considerations
In Ireland, the statute of limitations for medical negligence claims is usually two years; however, in the case of minors, this period does not begin until the child reaches the age of 18. Any parent or guardian has the right to bring a claim on behalf of their child, therefore it’s advisable to seek legal advice early to protect your child’s rights effectively.
Providing legal advice to families affected
The audit findings regarding unnecessary hip surgeries are extremely concerning and warrant serious scrutiny. If your family has been affected, and you would like to speak with a solicitor, arrange a callback from our legal team today by completing our confidential online form.
0 Comments