Established in 2005, the HSE operates under the Department of Health and is responsible for ensuring accessible, equitable, and quality care for the population. Services are provided through both direct operations and partnerships with voluntary and private organisations.
In 2025, the HSE allocated a budget of €26.9 billion to provide health and social care services across Ireland, a €1.6 billion increase from 2024. Despite this significant funding, individuals who have experienced substandard care using HSE services may feel uncertain about pursuing legal action for injuries they have sustained. Here are some key considerations regarding how the HSE is funded, the ethics of taking legal action, and how claims are dealt with.
How is the HSE funded?
It’s funded primarily through government allocations from Ireland’s annual budget, which are derived from taxation, including income tax, VAT, and corporate tax. These funds are allocated by the Department of Health to finance healthcare services nationwide. Additional revenue comes from charges for certain medical services, such as private patient fees in public hospitals and prescription charges under the medical card system. The HSE’s budget is one of the largest in the Irish public sector, reflecting its critical role in delivering healthcare to the population.
How is taxpayers’ money used?
The HSE uses taxpayers’ money to fund a wide range of healthcare and social services, including paying staff salaries, operating public hospitals, providing GP and community care, subsidising medications and prescriptions, and supporting long-term care for the elderly and people with disabilities. Funds are also allocated to mental health services, preventive health initiatives, vaccination programmes, and public health campaigns. Taxes also support the development and maintenance of healthcare infrastructure, emergency response systems, medical research, and administrative operations to ensure efficient service delivery.
Is it ethical to sue the HSE?
Given the vital services and initiatives funded by the HSE, some individuals may hesitate to pursue legal action after experiencing substandard care or medical errors, questioning whether it is ethical to do so. However, it’s important to note that the HSE does not pay claims from its annual budget. Instead, claims are managed by the Clinical Indemnity Scheme (CIS). Therefore, concerns about diverting funds from essential healthcare services should not deter patients from seeking compensation. Taking legal action is entirely ethical, especially when it holds parties accountable for negligence, harm, or malpractice. Moreover, such actions can expose systemic issues, drive improvements, and help prevent future harm. Patients have the right to justice and compensation when avoidable errors occur.
What is the Clinical Indemnity Scheme?
The CIS is an Irish government initiative providing indemnity cover for public healthcare providers, including the HSE and voluntary hospitals. Managed by the State Claims Agency, it addresses legal claims arising from medical malpractice or negligence within the public health system. The scheme aims to ensure compensation for patients harmed by substandard care while protecting healthcare staff and institutions from direct financial liability. By centralising claims management, the CIS promotes consistency, reduces legal costs, and identifies trends to improve patient safety and risk management in Ireland’s healthcare system.
What is not covered by the CIS?
The scheme does not cover private healthcare providers, private patient services within public hospitals, or incidents involving independent contractors or agencies. It excludes claims unrelated to clinical care, such as employment disputes, property damage, or general public liability issues. The scheme is designed specifically for clinical negligence within the public healthcare system, ensuring a focused scope of indemnity for patient care issues in HSE and voluntary hospitals.
How are CIS claims managed?
The State Claims Agency employs a team of Clinical Claims Managers with extensive legal knowledge and experience in managing clinical claims. This specialist team is solely responsible for deciding whether a claim should be settled or contested, based on a careful evaluation of the case details, legal factors, and potential outcomes.
Require assistance with a CIS claim?
If you have experienced substandard medical care as a patient of an HSE-funded service, you may have concerns and questions regarding your legal options. If you have suffered harm or injury and would like to speak to an experienced medical negligence solicitor, the McCarthy + Co team will be happy to assist you. Arrange a time to speak to a solicitor by completing our confidential online form.
0 Comments