Proving Undue Influence in a Will

Author Profile Picture
Couple concerned about a legal letter

When a will divides an estate in an unexpected way, family members sometimes suspect that someone close to the deceased pressured them into it. In Irish law, a will made following that kind of pressure, known as undue influence, can be declared invalid. Proving it, however, is notoriously difficult.

Our wills & probate team regularly advise families who have concerns about how a loved one’s will came to be made. In this short guide, I will explain what undue influence means, who has to prove it, and the kind of evidence the courts look for.

What counts as undue influence?

Undue influence is more than encouragement or persuasion. A relative is entitled to ask to be remembered in a will, and a will maker may be swayed by affection, gratitude, or a sense of duty. None of that is unlawful.

Influence becomes “undue” when it amounts to coercion: pressure that overpowers the will maker’s own judgement, so that the will reflects what someone else wanted rather than what the will maker freely decided. The pressure need not be physical. Persistent emotional pressure on a frail or dependent person, threats to withdraw care, or cutting someone off from family and friends can all, in the right circumstances, amount to coercion.

Who has to prove it?

The burden of proof rests entirely on the person alleging undue influence. With lifetime gifts, the law will sometimes presume undue influence because of the relationship between the parties. With wills, there is no such presumption. The High Court confirmed this in In the Goods of Kavanagh; Healy v MacGillicuddy [1978] ILRM 175, and it remains the position in Ireland today.

Courts must be satisfied that:

  • the person accused had the power or opportunity to influence the will maker;
  • undue influence was in fact exerted; and
  • the will was the product of that influence.

The court may draw inferences from the surrounding circumstances, but it will not act on suspicion or speculation. Because an allegation of undue influence is similar to an allegation of fraud, it must be set out in detail and should never be made lightly.

What evidence can help?

Direct evidence of coercion is rare, because it usually happens behind closed doors. Most cases are built from a combination of circumstances. Evidence that can support a claim includes:

  • Vulnerability. Medical records showing illness, frailty, cognitive decline, or dependence on others when the will was made.
  • Control. Whether the main beneficiary managed the will maker’s care, finances, post, or visitors.
  • Involvement in the will. Whether the beneficiary chose the solicitor, passed on instructions, attended meetings, or was present at the signing.
  • A sudden change. A will that departs sharply from earlier wills or from wishes expressed consistently over many years.
  • Isolation. Signs that family members or friends were discouraged or prevented from visiting.
  • Witness accounts. Statements from carers, neighbours, GPs, and others who saw the relationship at close quarters.
  • The solicitor’s file. Attendance notes, records of who gave instructions, and any capacity assessment obtained at the time.

No single factor proves undue influence on its own. A change of heart late in life, or a decision to reward the person who provided care, may be entirely genuine. The question is whether the evidence, taken as a whole, points to coercion rather than to any other reasonable explanation.

Related grounds of challenge

Because undue influence is so hard to establish, it is often raised alongside other grounds. Under section 77 of the Succession Act 1965, a will maker must be of sound disposing mind, so a lack of mental capacity may be argued where the will maker was unwell.

A challenger may also argue that the will maker did not know and approve of the contents of the will. Where suspicious circumstances surround the will, such as a beneficiary preparing it or arranging its signing, the court will expect those relying on the will to show that the will maker understood and approved what they signed.

Separately, a child who believes a parent failed to make proper provision for them may apply to court under section 117 of the Succession Act 1965. This does not involve proving undue influence, but the application must be brought within six months of the grant of probate.

How is a will challenged?

If you have concerns, the first practical step is often to lodge a caveat with the Probate Office or the relevant District Probate Registry. A caveat stops a grant of probate from being issued without notice to you. It lasts for six months and can be renewed.

If the dispute cannot be resolved, it will usually proceed as a probate action, in which the court decides whether the will is valid. If a will is set aside, the estate passes under an earlier valid will or, if there is none, under the rules of intestacy.

Claims to a share in an estate are generally subject to a six-year limitation period under section 45 of the Statute of Limitations 1957, as amended by the Succession Act 1965. You should not assume you have that long, however. Evidence fades, assets may be distributed, and delay can weaken a case. Litigation can also be costly, and the losing party may be ordered to pay the other side’s legal costs.

Protecting your own will from challenge

If you are making a will that you expect may be questioned, a few simple steps can make a challenge far less likely to succeed. Give instructions to your solicitor yourself and meet them without beneficiaries present. Where age or illness could later be raised, consider asking your doctor to confirm your capacity. If you are departing from an earlier will, a short note explaining your reasons can be valuable evidence.

At McCarthy + Co, we take these precautions as a matter of routine, so that our clients’ wishes are respected, and their families are spared a dispute.

Speak to our wills & probate team

If you have concerns about how a loved one’s will was made, or you are an executor facing a challenge, our wills & probate team here at McCarthy + Co Solicitors LLP can assess the evidence, explain your options, and act quickly to protect your position. Contact us today for a confidential, no-obligation consultation.

Paul McCarthy

Paul McCarthy has been an integral part of the team at McCarthy + Co Solicitors LLP since 2022. He plays an essential role in the preparation of personal injuries litigation, while also assisting colleagues with matters relating to wills, probate, conveyancing, and property law. Paul brings a meticulous, client-focused approach to his work, developed through his experience in both law and education. With a talent for breaking down complex legal topics, he contributes regularly to the McCarthy + Co blog, where his aim is to provide clear, straightforward advice that helps people better understand their legal rights.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Be Interested In